FACT CHECK: Quote Card Claiming ICC Prosecutor Backs Duterte’s Innocence Is FALSE

A quote card circulating online shows ICC Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang saying:

“In accordance with Rule 34, I am committed to supporting former President Rodrigo Duterte in his pursuit of the truth and ensuring a fair examination of the facts regarding his innocence.”

VERDICT: False

What the quote card gets wrong

There is no official ICC statement in which Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang says she is committed to “supporting Duterte’s innocence” or that she acted in accordance with “Rule 34” to do so.

In fact:

• Niang is responsible for the Office of the Prosecutor’s work on the Duterte case — which advances prosecution arguments, not defends the accused.

• Recent public filings by her office have opposed requests for interim release by Duterte’s legal team, arguing that continued detention is necessary. There is no support for the allegation that she has publicly endorsed Duterte’s innocence.

• No official ICC document or trustworthy news report contains the quote shown in the meme.

In short, the quote card fabricates a statement to imply support for Duterte that does not exist in ICC records or credible reporting.

What is “Rule 34”?

The quote card mentions “Rule 34” as if it authorizes a prosecutor to back an accused person. This is also incorrect.

Rule 34 in the ICC’s Rules of Procedure and Evidence

Under the ICC Rules of Procedure and Evidence, Rule 34 refers to disqualification of a judge, the Prosecutor, or a Deputy Prosecutor. Specifically, it lists circumstances in which they must be removed from a case due to potential bias or impropriety — for example:

• Personal interest in the case (e.g., close relationships to parties),

• Prior involvement in related legal proceedings, or

• Prior functions or public statements that reasonably raise questions about impartiality.

That is, Rule 34 does not empower the prosecutor to “support” a defendant — it sets out the grounds for disqualifying a prosecutor or judge if impartiality might be compromised.

There’s no ICC rule that says a prosecutor must support the innocence of any defendant — nor any provision like the one claimed in the quote card.

The only other widely known “Rule 34” is an internet meme meaning “there’s porn of everything, no exceptions” — entirely unrelated to ICC procedure.

BOTTOM LINE

The online quote card falsely claims that ICC Deputy Prosecutor Mame Mandiaye Niang made a statement endorsing Rodrigo Duterte’s innocence under “Rule 34.”

In reality, Rule 34 in ICC procedure concerns disqualification of officials, not support for any party in a case. There is no evidence that Niang issued the quoted statement or that such a rule exists in ICC practice.

About The Author

News Desk

Daily Sun Chronicle News Desk is a dynamic pool of writers, analysts, and field correspondents with diverse professional backgrounds and wide-ranging interests. Our team brings together seasoned journalists, emerging storytellers, subject-matter specialists, and community-based researchers who share a common commitment to truth-telling and public service.

See author's posts